Birthdays, holidays, family get-togethers, office parties, or just to have a great dessert around the house. All of our cakes are individually hand-packed and artfully decorated. We always have a wide selection in stock, or with a two day notice, you may call to custom order your own. You select the base of the cake, your favorite ice cream (or yogurt) flavors, an optional filling, decoration style, finishing touches, and an inscription.

Email and faxed orders MUST be verified over the phone. Please follow up with a confirmation phone call to verify receipt of order 617-964-9200

Custom ordered cakes are made on Tuesday, Thursday & Saturday. Orders need to be in two days prior.

Order Form

cake slice close up - layers explained albert einstein explains cabot's ice cream cakes! cake slice close up - layers explained

1. Cake Sizes

Size Shape Servings Price*
6 inch Round 4-6 $ 32.99
8 inch Round 8-12 $ 39.99
9 inch Round 12-18 $ 45.99
10 inch Round 18-25 $ 53.99
12 inch Round 25-30 $ 62.99
10x14 inch Rectangle 30-35 $ 74.99
12x18 inch Rectangle 35-45 $ 86.99

* Starting cake prices do not include fillings, custom themes,
or edible photo images

2. The Base of the Cake

Select a Base (just one)

Chocolate Cake sample chocolate base
Gold Cake sample gold cake base
Chocolate Crunchies sample chocolate crunchies cake base
Chocolate Crunchies - Gluten Free sample gluten free chocolate crunchies cake base
Crushed Oreo® sample crushed oreo cake base
Vanilla Chunchies sample Vanilla crunchies cake base
Graham Cracker sample graham crackers cake base
Banana Slices sample bananas cake base

NOTE: Cake bases can also be used in between layers
as an optional filling. See section 4.

3. Ice Cream Flavors

You may select
1-3 Ice Cream Flavors OR Frozen Yogurt flavors.

4. Optional Fillings

A Filling is an optional layer between
the ice cream or frozen yogurt.
There is an additional charge for fillings.

Regular Fillings

  • Chocolate Chips
  • Chocolate Crunchies
  • Chocolate Crunchies - Gluten Free
  • Cookie Dough Pieces
  • Crushed Graham Crackers
  • Crushed Oreo's®
  • Crushed Peanut Butter Cups
  • Crushed Snickers®
  • Granola
  • Malt Powder
  • Mini M&M's®
  • Mini Reeses® Pieces
  • Nestle's Crunch®
  • Vanilla Crunchies
  • Whoppers®

Cake Layers as a Filling

  • Chocolate Cake Layer
  • Gold Cake Layer
  • Gluten Free Chocolate Crunchies

Fudges & Sauces as a Filling

  • Butter Fudge
  • Bittersweet Fudge (semi-sweet)
  • Mellocream Fudge (milk chocolate)
  • Sugar Free Fudge
  • Butterscotch
  • Caramel
  • Peanut Butter Sauce
  • Raspberry Sauce
  • Colored Frosting
fudge dripping from spoon
crushed oreo's filling
snickers filling
butterscotch filling
chocolate chip filling
whoppers filling
chocolate crunchies filling
vanilla crunchies filling
mini m&m's filling
resses filling
crunched peanut buttercup filling
crushed oreo's filling
crunch filling

5. Cake Decoration Style

Here are your Cake Decoration Style Choices.

Candy Shoppe Ice Cream Cakes
sample candy shoppe ice cream cake
We start with a thin layer of cake, pile on ice cream, cover with a delicious chocolate fudge on the top, then trim the boarders with frosting leaving the ice cream visible on the sides. It is decorated with a drizzle of sauce and then finished with complementing candies, cookies, or fruit.
Traditional Ice Cream Cakes
sample traditional decorated ice cream cake
We frost the entire cake using a white (or colored) non-dairy cream frosting and finish with trim and your choice of flowers, sprinkles, confetti, or items listed in section 6 below.

6. Decoration Style

Here are your Cake Decoration Style Choices.

Photo Image Ice Cream Cakes
sample photo image ice cream cake
Email us your photo or logo, and we will scan the image onto an edible image frosting layer which is then applied to the top of the cake.
Theme Ice Cream Cakes
sample theme ice cream cake
Children's themes, Cartoon Characters, Holidays, Sports, Corporate Parties, and Special Events.
Check out our "Theme Ice Cream Cakes" page for examples.
Some Additional Ideas / Suggestions
Specialty Ice Cream Cakes
sample spumoni log specialty ice cream cake
Examples include: Banana Split Cake, Chocolate Homocide, Strawberry Shortcake, Spumoni Log, Mud Pie, Baked Alaska, etc.
Click here to view our selection.
Frozen Yogurt Pies
sample frozen yogurt raspberry pie
Made in a pie crust shell, filled with custom blended frozen yogurt, trimmed with a piping of frosting, and decorated.
Gluten Free pie crust shells are available.
Graduation Themed Ice Cream Cakes
sample graduation themed ice cream cakes
Decorated with your school's colors and theme.
Holiday Ice Cream Cakes Cakes
sample holiday themed ice cream cakes
Holiday themed cakes are available in stock or call to custom order one.

7. Finishing Touches to the Outside of Your Cake

You may complement your ice cream selection with
candy, sprinkles, fruit, and/or drizzle.
Select from below.

Candy & Sprinkles

  • Chocolate Chips
  • Chocolate Crunchies
  • Gluten Free Chocolate Crunchies
  • Chocolate Jimmies
  • Coconut
  • Confetti - Pastel
  • Confetti - Bright
  • Cookie Dough Pieces
  • Crushed Graham Crackers
  • Crushed Oreo's®
  • Crushed Peanut Buttercups
  • Crushed Snickers®
  • Granola
  • Gummy Bears
  • Holiday Colored Sprinkles
  • Malt Powder
  • Mini M&M's®
  • Mini Reeses® Pieces
  • Nestle's®Crunch
  • Rainbow Sprinkles
  • Vanilla Crunchies
  • Whoppers®

Fruit Selection

  • Banana
  • Blueberry
  • Coconut
  • Peach
  • Pineapple
  • Raspberry
  • Strawberry

Drizzle with

  • Caramel
  • Chocolate
  • Marshmallow
  • Peanut Butter
chocolate crunchies finishing
just a drizzle
pastel confetti
mini m&m's
reese's pieces
crushed peanut buttercups
vanilla crunch
gummy bears
chocolate crunch
bright confetti
halloween sprinkles
rainbow sprinkles
crushed heath candy
reese's pieces
m&m's finishing halloween sprinkles finishing

8. Personalized Inscription

What would you like your cake to say?


Here are some examples of cake inscriptions.

just a drizzle
just a drizzle
just a drizzle
just a drizzle
just a drizzle
just a drizzle

For your convenience you may prepay your cake order here.

pay using paypal;

Order Form

Here is a batch of Chocolate Base, Round Ice Cream Cakes on the way.

making ice cream cakes making ice cream cakes making ice cream cakes